reel choice

[Amish Ed]

So, I received a $150 gift certificate to Big 5. I went in hopes of a Shimano baitcaster, but they don't stock them. My only options are the Abu Garcia Black Max and the Daiwa Lexa 300. BIG price difference. I decided to get the Black Max as it is smaller. Got to the counter and their computer was down. I left wondering if I was making the right decision. If I get the Lexa I have to wait to get braid for it and also probably curtail the begining of my 2015 season as I wouldn't be able to purchase my License. On the other hand the Black Max would allow for both of those now.

Anyone out there use both? Black Max opinions? Lexa Opinions?

[YakDout]

Lexas are really nice. I have a 3 and 400. Low maintenance reels and good drags. I've never used a black max, but I stopped buying ABU's after some bad experiences with a revo toro.

[buddha]

Originally Posted by YakDout

Lexas are really nice. I have a 3 and 400. Low maintenance reels and good drags. I've never used a black max, but I stopped buying ABU's after some bad experiences with a revo toro.

What issues did you have with the Revo Toro?

A lot of people like the Abu reels especially the NACL.

[MrPatrick]

The Lexa is more durable reel.the black max is a very basic reel. If you were down here in S.D., I would bring some braid with me to Tidelands Saturday and give it to you. Red 50# Power Pro.

[YakDout]

That's the one I had. Toro 50 NaCl. Constant problems with going into freespool and not going back into gear. I would have to smack the side of the reel to get it back. Two other people I know had the exact same problem. This was after servicing a couple times mind you. And after some big fish my reel was VERY rough internally. Switched to a lexa 300 and liked it so much I also have a 400 now which is one of my favorite reels.

[buddha]

Originally Posted by YakDout

That's the one I had. Toro 50 NaCl. Constant problems with going into freespool and not going back into gear. I would have to smack the side of the reel to get it back. Two other people I know had the exact same problem. This was after servicing a couple times mind you. And after some big fish my reel was VERY rough internally. Switched to a lexa 300 and liked it so much I also have a 400 now which is one of my favorite reels.

That surprises me about the Abu Garcia Toro Nacl. I have a Lexa 300 and it is a nice reel but not the smoothest one I have used. My search continues for another lefty baitcaster. Haven't tried the Avets yet and may give them a try.

[pray4BIGfish]

do yourself a favor and buy something worth 150$ with the gift card and then return it the next day and get cashback, i won a trout derby this year and received the exact same amount to big 5, big 5 sucks a$$ as far as fishing gear is concerned... get your money and wait for the boat show in march if you can wait that long, and i have 2 revo toros, never had a problem with either of them, caught a stupid amount of yellows and football grade tuna (10-20lbs) this year on the 50 NaCl.. also 2 of my buddies (one of them is Wes who works at Kens custom reels) caught an 81 AND 84lb yellowfin on the 50 this year, they tried to break the reel to no avail.. needless to say they didn't use that reel for the rest of their trip, muscle failure not mechanical lol

[YakDout]

So you're saying that a saltist BG sucks ass? But only because it is from big 5? I've seen some smokin deals at big 5 for quality rods AND reels. Not every store has the same stuff in stock. Do yourself a favor and look/call around. They have some quality stuff at great prices. Sometime it seems like they don't know what they're selling.

[pray4BIGfish]

Originally Posted by YakDout

So you're saying that a saltist BG sucks ass? But only because it is from big 5? I've seen some smokin deals at big 5 for quality rods AND reels. Not every store has the same stuff in stock. Do yourself a favor and look/call around. They have some quality stuff at great prices. Sometime it seems like they don't know what they're selling.

why would I go to a bunch different stores to look for their *maybe* 2 good reels that they have (that they themselves probably don't even know they have) lol, when you can choose from so many more reels at BETTER prices when the boat show comes into town by getting cash back?

[pray4BIGfish]

.. and maybe i should rephrase the "big 5 sucks a$$", i should have said "big 5 sucks a$$ compared to the major majority of other stores that sell fishing gear" haha

[exfactor]

Did you know that all the rods they sell are seconds? That should tip you off there.

[easyday]

I have some rods and reels from Big 5 that have outlasted my other high end gear. I have a rod I paid 40 bucks for that has caught it's fair share of decent fish. It helps that my wife works there so she can check every stores inventory and just get me the stuff I want, no they don't have what your high end tackle stores do but saying that they suck is a pretty bold statement......I have a sealine that I bought 2 years ago and it has seen some Nasty abuse with no services. Now I use it just to see how long it's going to last. I want to say the sealine reels are like the glocks of fishing reels.

[Amish Ed]

Well, it turns out it was a Pro Max, not the Black Max. I went ahead and got it as I really don't need another 300 size, and did want another small one. Loaded up some #30 Power Pro and I'm good to go.

Thank you for all the replies. As too Big 5, I wish they had a better selection like the used to. But, you can get some deals there.

[pray4BIGfish]

Originally Posted by easyday

I have some rods and reels from Big 5 that have outlasted my other high end gear. I have a rod I paid 40 bucks for that has caught it's fair share of decent fish. It helps that my wife works there so she can check every stores inventory and just get me the stuff I want, no they don't have what your high end tackle stores do but saying that they suck is a pretty bold statement......I have a sealine that I bought 2 years ago and it has seen some Nasty abuse with no services. Now I use it just to see how long it's going to last. I want to say the sealine reels are like the glocks of fishing reels.

i can understand you defending where your wife works, but you should especially know then that they barely carry any DECENT variety of good fishing gear.. i own a few Sealines myself and yes they're great reels but they literally have a handful of good reels.. defend them if you want but facts are facts. You want more than a few choices? search elsewhere or be confined to choosing from a limited selection.. but hey some ppl like to have their options limited, I'm not one of them

[lowprofile]

Big 5 in solona beach always had good deals.

[Reel Anxious]

Originally Posted by pray4BIGfish

i can understand you defending where your wife works, but you should especially know then that they barely carry any DECENT variety of good fishing gear.. i own a few Sealines myself and yes they're great reels but they literally have a handful of good reels.. defend them if you want but facts are facts. You want more than a few choices? search elsewhere or be confined to choosing from a limited selection.. but hey some ppl like to have their options limited, I'm not one of them

Who are you? After six posts you drop in to diss one of our members? Take it on the heel. Shoo fly shoo